Edited by Azizi Powell
This pancocojams post presents information about the African American originated call & response saying "God is good" / "All The Time".
This post also presents selected comments from the Black discussion thread lipstick alley.com about the saying "God is good" / "All the time".
The content of this post is presented for historical and cultural purposes.
All copyrights remain with their owners.
Thanks to all those who are quoted in this post.
****
INFORMATION ABOUT THE SAYING "GOD IS GOOD" / "ALL THE TIME"
"God is good" / "All the time" is a call and response saying that is most likely of African American origin although no one has been identified as its originator. A number of commentators on discussion threads for various YouTube videos and in some online articles specifically indicate that "God is good" /"All the time" originally comes from African American Protestant churches in the United States South.
During church services, a pastor or some other leader says "God is good" and the congregation automatically responds "All the time". Traditionally, the pastor or leader then says "All the time" and the congregation automatically says "God is good".
The first part of this call and response saying is also sometimes used in non-religious settings, for instance as a response to hearing good news. For instance, a person tells her friend some good news. The friend may then say "God is good" and the first person responds "All the time".
The earliest documentation that I have found for this call and response saying is a 1995 Gospel record by Pastor Alvin Darling entitled "God Is Good"/ All The Time". However, it's likely that that saying was in use before that song was composed, recorded, and released.
Here are hyperlinks for pancocojams posts that showcase African American Gospel records with the itle "God Is Good" / "All The Time" or with the title "God Is Good", but which also include those words and the response "All the time":
https://pancocojams.blogspot.com/2024/07/alvin-darling-celebration-god-is-good.html "God Is Good All The Time" recorded by Pastor Alvin Darling 1995)
https://pancocojams.blogspot.com/2024/07/chester-d-t-baldwin-god-is-good-2000.html
"God Is Good" (2000) recorded by Chester D. T. Baldwin.
https://pancocojams.blogspot.com/2024/07/regina-belle-god-is-good-youtube-gospel.html "God Is Good" (2008) by Regina Belle.
In addition, a Gospel song entitled "God Is Good All The Time" was recorded in 1998 by (White American) Don Moen. Click https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=Q376chG2yDs for a YouTube video of that song.
****
RECENT COMMENTS ABOUT THE SAYING "GOD IS GOOD ALL THE TIME"
On March 25, 2024 controversial Black Conservative commentator Candace Owens was interviewed on the popular radio show "The Breakfast Club".
As is the custom of the hosts of that radio show, toward the end of that interview, Candace Owens was asked several questions about "Black culture". When she was asked for the response to the saying "God is good", Candace said "Amen" instead of saying "All the time". The hosts then gave the correct response and indicated that response is something that almost all Black people know.
https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=goIrzPIh8yA&t=804s time stamp:1:06:23
The video clip of that interview has been widely circulated on African American podcasts. Some podcasters and/or commenters have facetiously or seriously indicated that knowing the correct answer to that saying is part of a "test" that determines whether a person in the United States is Black or not.
****
SELECTED COMMENTS FROM VARIOUS YOUTUBE DISCUSSION THREADS ABOUT THE SAYING "GOD IS GOOD ALL THE TIME"
This is one of many online discussion thread of online videos about the saying "God is Good All The Time" that were published because of the March 2024 The Breakfast Club segment with Candace Owens.
These selected comments are given in no particular order and are numbered for referencing purposes only.
From https://www.lipstickalley.com/threads/so-is-%E2%80%9Cgod-is-good%E2%80%9D-really-a-black-american-test-lol.5589303/ So is “God is Good” really a Black American test? lol, April 19, 2024
Pancocojams Editor's Note- Lipstick Alley.com was started in the United States as an online discussion thread for Black people. Almost all of the commenters are Black and it appears that most of those commenters are still from the United States.
1.Sundaedinner, thread starter
So I’m sure y’all saw Candace Owens try and fail the “God is
Good” test, right?
So why I was listening to the Joe Budden podcast and they were talking about this being a Black test.
They started saying the God is great, Good is good. Let us thank him for our food, prayer.
And they were really confused and I was dying because I did not know why I thought this saying was as universal as that prayer.
Don’t finish the phrase!!!!!
But tell me if you CAN you finish the phrase!!!
I want to know if you know the phrase lmaoooo"
-snip-
"ADOS" = "Americans Descendants of Slaves", a relatively recently formed movement/ideology/lineage; Foundational Black American (FBA) is a very similar movement, ideology, lineage. Click https://pancocojams.blogspot.com/2024/06/article-excerpts-about-population.html "Article Excerpts About The Population Referents "ADOS" (American Descendants Of Slaves) And "FBA" (Foundational Black Americans)".
**
2. Sundaedinner, April 19, 2024
"awayzright said:
All sayings like this aren't completely universal in black
culture. Black Catholics don't do this call response in Mass, lol
But even if you didn’t grow up saying this, you had to have heard this before.
It’s so common."
**
3. Alleybux, April 19, 2024
"Sundaedinner said:
lol it’s not a prayer.
It’s a saying.
Like your grandma or auntie would say it. Or really anybody.
It is said in church but most times it’s just said if something
good happens.
ohhh ya I associate it w prayer cuz only my religious fam
say stuff like that fr
u gotta forgive me I’m in the South I love God but allat extra is exhausting
4.
"Sundaedinner said:
But even if you didn’t grow up saying this, you had to have
heard this before.
It’s so common.
It depends on a lot of factors. It's very possible for black
people to have not been exposed to this and a lot of other sayings assumed to
be universal in black culture. Yes there are a lot of sayings and customs that
are deeply embedded in black culture, but to say knowing or not knowing any one
of them is proof that you are or aren't really black is ridiculous."
**
5. Sundaedinner, Apr 19, 2024
"alwayzright said:
It depends on a lot of factors. It's very possible for black
people to have not been exposed to this and a lot of other sayings assumed to
be universal in black culture. Yes there are a lot of sayings and customs that
are deeply embedded in black culture, but to say knowing or not knowing any one
of them is proof that you are or aren't really black is ridiculous.
If you read my original post and the fact that the title was a question you can tell it was tongue in cheek.
However there are universal sayings that 90-95% of Black
Americans know."
**
6. Sundaedinner, Apr 19, 2024
New Miracles said:
I didn't learn of this until I was an adult. It had to
originate in the deep south tho. Now that it's being promoted the Kardashian's
will probably start saying it
Lmaoooooo yea I think it probably did originate in the south
but so many people migrated to the North and West I know it’s said there too."
**
7.
"Beverly417 said:
Preacher: God is good
Congregation: All the time
Preacher: And all the time
Congregation: God is good
And the preacher usually says it right before the sermon.
It's like a call to attention sometimes to end a fellowship
period or to close out a spontaneous praise and worship outbreak.
But some people will also use it in day to day speech.
Like did you hear Sally is home from the hospital...God is good...
...all the time..."
**
8. Buffalo Butt, Apr 19, 2024
"Today I posted about how a lot of people today are godless.
They don’t know anything about interactions and greetings in church.
Someone gives you good news “I got a promotion” the response depending on their generation will be “God is good” and you respond “all the time” somebody who only heard that part the interaction might chime in “I know that’s right” and you all end up praising the lord for a minute.
I want to go back down south! These heathens don’t know
anything!"
**
9. Applesauce1978, Apr 19, 2024
"Imo or the way I was raised to use it was: it isn’t a test
but a TESTIMONY. You stated it after something positive happened or with faith
that something positive would happen."
**
10.alwayzright, Apr 19, 2024
"Sundaedinner said:
If you read my original post and the fact that the title
was a question you can tell it was tongue in cheek.
However there are universal sayings that 90-95% of Black Americans know.
Lol, I get it. Of course it's not a serious test, but some
people will act like it is. And culturisms have changed and evolved drastically
in the internet/social media age. There was a time when different cultures were
segregated from each other and we bonded through our use of language and
colloquialisms. Now everyone is exposed to everything, so sayings that meant
something to everyone in our community 50 years ago don't even register with
people who were born after the internet and smart phones were commonplace.
Their great-grandmother may have said "God is good, all the time",
but they mama and them is talking about how many likes they got."
**
From https://www.lipstickalley.com/threads/so-is-%E2%80%9Cgod-is-good%E2%80%9D-really-a-black-american-test-lol.5589303/page-2
11. chiwe, Apr 19, 2024
"Buffalo Butt said:
ALL THE TIME!!!! My migraine is worsening just reading
this thread.
Who raised these people?!
My husband is catholic, deep in Catholicism and still responded correctly to God is good.
I was raised Catholic too, and I know it! I'm surprised by
the black people who don't, lol."
**
12.
"It’s a generational/cultural thing. If you’re at least older
Gen Z, and you grew up with a real grandmother—old school, God fearing, gospel
listening, went to church every Sunday regardless of denomination—or you were
raised in the church, you’d be more familiar with that saying. These youngins
got grandmothers who are 46 and who haven’t been inside a church since Easter
Sunday 1998. Furthermore, when they are around the old folks, they’re not
eavesdropping and acting like they’re not like how we did back in the day,
which is how we picked up the sayings of our elders. They’re too busy in their
phones, with their headphones on, that they’re not paying attention to what’s
going on around them"
**
13. nevershoutnever, Apr 19, 2024
"My parents aren't even from America but my grandmother had
us all in church from a young age so I'd heard it since I was young. The other
day an older BM said it to me and it stopped me in my tracks lol. Reminded me
of my granny. I really only hear it from older black people unfortunately."
**
14. dailylife, Apr 19, 2024
"I feel like if you’ve been in this country a long time, you
ought to know it. I’m not ADOS and I knew it."
**
15. TSquared, Apr 19, 2024
"Of course I know the phrase.
-snip-
IYKYK=”If you know, you know”
16.
"A lot of non-Black people would pass that test and a lot of
Black people would not. It's a Southern Protestant thing. Of course, Southern
Protestantism (and Southern culture in general) is heavily influenced by
Southern Black Americans. I wouldn't expect all Black Americans to know
something that's a part of such a specific group"
**
17. Sundaedinner, April 19, 2024
"I never heard white people say this and this is said all
over the US. It’s probably said more in the South. But I think it’s said other
areas too."
**
18. nocturnalis, April 19, 2024
"If you are ADOS, and don’t know this, I’m going to give you
a side eye, idc."
**
19. TSquared, April 19, 2024
"Idk.
**
20. BlaqAmethyst, Apr 19, 2024
"Well I guess I failed too! When I saw the Candace video I was confused as to why everyone was clowning her. Like I was watching it thinking what was she supposed to say because I didn't immediately get it either."
**
21. Earthenware Kitt, April 19, 2024
"Sundaedinner said:
Yall really disappointing me.
At least it's being revealed who's a Foundational Black
American and who's not.
And yes, I've even heard African people say "God is good, all the time."
If someone Black hasn't heard it at least once?
That's at least...Odd."
**
22. Lurkin2020, Apr 20, 2024
"I think it’s universally FBA. It’s so commonly said that
even I know what it is and I wasn’t raised in The Black Church. If you grew up
in FBA culture, you know it’s so ubiquitous, that it’s part of the everyday
lexicon of idioms within the various regional AAVE dialects across the country.
ETA: As far as it being a test —no. It’s not like it’s something we test each other on to see if they’re FBA or anything.
Do Caribbeans say this to test FBAs, Afro-Latinos, or Africans and their direct diaspora?
And yes, of course I know the proper response. "
**
23. Haitian1, Apr 20, 2024
"im Not African American and knew this cause i
visited many African American churchs when i was a kid lol"
**
24. Hi5Perry, April 20, 2024
Accurate! And
throw in "May not come when you want Him" if you want to catch
a Black Christian
Sundaedinner said:
I never heard white people say this and this is said all
over the US. It’s probably said more in the South. But I think it’s said other
areas too.
I've always attended "white"/mixed churches.
I've heard Black/white/Latino people say it all my life.
-snip-
The correct response to the African American call “He may not come when you want Him” is “But He’s always right on time”.
**
25. Elowen, Apr 20, 2024
"Damn. I would have failed this.
I don't know it at all.
I'm 100% FBA both sides of my family.
Oh well. Lol!"
**
26.
"Elowen said:
Damn. I would have failed this.
I don't know it at all.
I'm 100% FBA both sides of my family.
Oh well. Lol!
Lol you good. They always saying the BC is not a monolith
but claim “you ain’t black” if you ever fall out of step with what they
consider the norm. Lol"
-snip-
"BC"= "the Black community"
**
27.
"I’m Canadian.. this is standard in the West Indian and
multicultural SDA churches I’ve been to, and I can imagine beyond.
Some people didn’t grow up in church like that, a church
that says that, or may even just have a brain fart when put on the spot. I
don’t think the results of this test prove or disprove what the tester is
intending."
**
28. Sundaedinner, Apr 20, 2024
TSquared said:
Idk.
I didn't grow up with the phrase in church. I'm 45. I
don't think I started hearing it in church til I was in my 20s. But maybe this
varies by location?
Probably.
Maybe it is a south thing but I know I’ve heard it up north
and in the Midwest. So idk."
**
29. Sundaedinner, Apr 20, 2024
"The test part was tongue in cheek because I honestly did
think this was a universal saying and was shocked with the amount of people who
didn’t know it."
**
"I know the phrase, but I was bought up in the church by a
pious West African father and they'd say this at KICC."
-snip-
Here's information about KICC:
https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Kingsway_International_Christian_Centre
"Kingsway International Christian Centre (KICC) is based in
London, England and was established in 1992 with 200 adults and 100 children.
It currently has up to 12,000 people in attendance at the main church every
Sunday.[1] The church is pastored by Matthew Ashimolowo.
The church, whose majority membership is under 50 years of
age, is predominantly of West African origin but claims that worshippers come
from 46 nations.[2] It was located for nine years on a 9.5-acre (38,000 m2)
site in Hackney, London, close to the site of the 2012 Olympics Village.”…
****
Thanks for visiting pancocojams.
Visitor comments are welcome.
