Translate

Showing posts with label black faced minstrelsy. Show all posts
Showing posts with label black faced minstrelsy. Show all posts

Saturday, July 11, 2026

Five YouTube Examples Of The Mid 19th Century American Song "Old Dan Tucker" (Part II)

 

Ol' Dan Tucker From the Second South Carolina String Band.

rosestar77, Uploaded on Feb 19, 2010

Shot in Gettysburg, PA.
-snip-

This YouTube video includes lyrics captions. I believe that some of those lyrics are incorrect, for instance, the word "sucker" instead of the last name "Tucker."

****
Edited by Azizi Powell

This is Part II of a pancocojams series on the American minstrel/play party song "Old Dan Tucker" (also given as "Ole Dan Tucker").

This post showcases YouTube examples of the song "Old Dan Tucker."  This post also includes some information about and lyrics for versions of that song.

Click https://pancocojams.blogspot.com/2026/07/the-black-american-roots-of.html for Part I of this pancocojams series. That post presents information and commentary about the history of the song "Old Dan Tucker".

Much of the content of this series was published in a different format in this 2013 post: 

This 2026 post also includes the three comments that were published in that 2013 post as of July 11, 2026.* However, the videos of that song that were included in that 2013 post are now showcased in Part II of this 2026 pancocojams post. 

The content of this post is presented for folkloric, historical, and educational purposes.

All copyrights remain with their owners.

****
Thanks to the unknown early composers of this song. Thanks to all those who are quoted in this post. Thanks to the performers & musicians who are featured in these videos, and thanks to the producers of these videos on YouTube.

****
ADDITIONAL VIDEOS OF "OLD DAN TUCKER"
These videos are given in no particular order and are numbered for referencing purposes only. 

SHOWCASE VIDEO #2 - Ol Dan Tucker


AMSOMmp, Uploaded on Jul 7, 2009


Andy and Opie sings Ol Dan Tucker [from the American television series "The Andie Griffin Show".]

****
SHOWCASE VIDEO #3 - 
Mr. Edwards (Victor French) - Old Dan Tucker

danieljano88 Dec 30, 2012

From Little House on the Praire

Episode 4, 1st Season: Mr. Edwards Homecoming

So funny

I don't own the video. Just for entertaining.

****
SHOWCASE  VIDEO #4-  Bruce Springsteen with the Sessions Band - Old Dan Tucker (Live In Dublin)


Bruce Springsteen, Mar 4, 2019



****
SHOWCASE VIDEO #5-
Ol Dan Tucker


Mr.Hudspeth's Music Channel, Nov 9, 2017

Old Dan Tucker is a classic American folk song with roots deep in the 19thcentury oral tradition. The tune circulated widely before it was ever written down, and many historians connect the earliest published lyrics to Dan Emmett, a wellknown American songwriter of the 1800s. The first sheetmusic edition appeared in 1843, but the song itself is olderpassed from singer to singer long before it reached print. Because of its age and traditional transmission, Old Dan Tucker is firmly in the Public Domain.

This arrangement is created specifically for kids, classrooms, and elementary music teachers who want a simple, joyful, easytosing version of this beloved folk song. It works beautifully as a singalong, echo song, warmup, or folksong lesson for grades K5.

I, David Hudspeth, arranged, recorded, and produced this entire video. This is my original educational arrangement, created to reflect how the song might have been sung in its early days—simple, rhythmic, and full of energy.

🎵 What makes this version kidfriendly?

Easy melody for young singers

Clear echostyle phrases for callandresponse

Steady beat for movement activities

Folkstyle guitar and voice arrangement

Perfect for elementary music, homeschool, parents, and classroom teachers


🎶 Why teach “Old Dan Tucker”?

It’s a traditional American folk song with strong cultural and historical value

Great for teaching steady beat, echo singing, callandresponse, and folksong form

Works well for music programs, sub plans, warmups, and singalong days

Helps students connect with early American music traditions

 

📚 Song Background (KidFriendly Summary) 

“Old Dan Tucker” has been sung for nearly 200 years. No one knows exactly who wrote the original version, but it became widely known in the 1840s and has appeared in countless songbooks, school music curriculums, and folk collections ever since. Because the author is unknown and the song predates modern copyright, it is Public Domain."...
-snip-
This "Kid-Friendly" summary doesn't include any information about the Black American origins of early versions of this song. Read Part I of this pancocojams series including this comment that I wrote on July 11, 2026:

 Azizi PowellJuly 11, 2026 at 11:38 AM

For what ever reason, I woke up today with the song "Old Dan Tucker" in my mind. I didn't remember publishing this 2013 pancocojams post, but searched for it on this blog and found this post.

More than five years later, I wish I had expanded upon my response to unknown's comment . Here's my response now:

With regard to my comment that "every person has to make up her and his mind about the use of compositions that are categorized as "minstrel songs", I realize that now (in the 2020s United States if not elsewhere, the school system's administrators determine which subjects are taught in music classes, history classes, and "social studies" classes (if "social studies classes even still exist in the United States since the beginning of the 21st century).


I still believe that the full history of the song "Old Day Tucker" should be taught to older students (i.e students in the 6th grade on up) and to intellectually advanced students. The black faced minstrel history of that song (and of many other American "old time" songs), is part of those song's full histories. Not including that history is "white washing' those songs and therefore not paying homage to their original Black composers, or their early Black composers.

Furthermore, not providing age appropriate information about America's past-including Black faced minstrelsy that was performed by White singers/musicians and by Black singers/musicians robs children and youth of opportunities to learn from this nation's past-including lessons about how people were (and still are) mistreated, treated unequally under the law, and/or ridiculed because of their race, ethnicity, gender, religion etc.

For these reasons, I support the introduction and teaching of old time music to children and youth. However, I believe that prior to university level, students should be informed-in age appropriate language-that they are learning modified versions of these songs. My sense is that those modified versions shouldn't include the n word", Ebonics dialect, and negative references to race and gender when they are sung for entertainment purpose."

****
This concludes Part II of this pancocojams series.

Thanks for visiting pancocojams.

Visitor comments are welcome.

Wednesday, November 22, 2023

2017 Journal Article Excerpt: "Jim Along Josey": Play-Parties and the Survival of a Blackface Minstrel Song

Edited by Azizi Powell

This pancocojams post presents a long excerpt from the 2017 Journal article by Maya Brown about the song "Jim Along Josie" as an example of a black faced minstrel song that became a play party song.

The content of this post is presented for folkloric, cultural, and educational purposes.

All copyrights remain with their owners.

Thanks to Maya Brown for her research and writing and thanks all those who are quoted in this post. Thanks also to the online publisher of this journal article.
-snip-
Click https://pancocojams.blogspot.com/2013/08/examples-of-dance-josey-cant-dance.html for the closely related 2013 pancocojams post entitled "Examples of "Dance Josey" & "Can't Dance Josey" Songs".

****
JOURNAL ARTICLE EXCERPT
From https://oaks.kent.edu/sites/default/files/journals/2/articles/45/submission/stamped.pdf Excellence In Performing Arts Research, Volume 4, 2017

"Jim Along Josey": Play-Parties and the Survival of a Blackface Minstrel Song

by Maya Brown

 [page] 1

Abstract

The play-party was a social activity once practiced in rural America amongst Protestants in the latter half of the nineteenth century. With a desire to circumvent the church’s strict no dancing rules, as well as avoid reprimand, play-party adolescents adapted the lyrics and instrumentation of blackface minstrel songs to create a vocal music to accompany their playparty games. The main objective of this paper is to demonstrate that play-parties offered the space for the continuation and reinterpretation of minstrel practices, particularly song repertoire.

In this paper, the children’s song “Jim Along Josey” is used as a case study, first to reveal the role of songs in play-parties, and secondly to demonstrate the process of musical reinterpretation that characterized this social event. The study also reveals that minstrel songs such as this have survived within the genre of children’s music due to the reinterpretation conducted by play-party adolescents.

Introduction

Although American blackface minstrelsy is no longer a socially acceptable form of entertainment in the United States, remnants of its musical characteristics linger in the songs frequently taught to children.

Some of the most nostalgic songs in children’s music repertoire— i.e. “Jimmy Crack Corn,” “The Little Brown Jug,” “Camptown Races,” “Shoo Fly, Don’t Bother Me,” “Oh, Susanna,” and “Do Your Ears Hang Low?”—were at one time sung in blackface performance.

 All too often, American children encounter former minstrel songs in elementary schools, summer camps, children’s television shows and music albums rarely with the opportunity to know that these songs were once performed on the minstrel stage.

The minstrel show was a popular nineteenth century stage performance, which entertained audiences by exploiting African American stereotypes. These productions contained overtly prejudice themes that were, and continue to be, detrimental to the black individual. The minstrel song was particularly dehumanizing for its derogatory lyrics that aided in the creation of fictitious African American caricatures.

Interestingly, it seems contemporary children’s songs based on this genre have omitted these offenses. Upon comparing the lyrics of the two genres, it is observed that an adaptation, perhaps even an expurgation occurred to render the song appropriate for a child. By tracing the history of the children’s song “Jim Along Josey,” this paper hopes to reveal how the former minstrel song has managed to survive into the modern day.

[...]

[page] 2

[...]

 Amid the folk genres collected throughout America was the children’s song. According to ethnomusicologists Patricia Shehan Campbell and Trevor Wiggins, children’s songs appeared to be of great interest to scholars from the end of the nineteenth century to the last years of the twentieth century, and folklorists valued children’s song as a source of social expression and cultural material much like folk songs.

Benjamin A Botkin And Play-Party Songs

One such folklorist was Benjamin A. Botkin, who in 1937 published his doctoral dissertation about the American play-party.

In this work, Botkin collected over 1,000 variations of 128 play-party songs from students at the University of Oklahoma. Botkin began his research in the early 1930s with the focus of collecting and preserving an oral tradition that was on the verge of dying. After conducting his research, however, it became apparent to him that the playparty was a unique form of social behavior; one that would intrigue scholars for years to come.

[…]

[page] 3

[…]

Botkin identified the value of collecting play-party songs and believed they provided the key to understanding American rural cultures and communities. As he described in the quote above, play-parties were multilayered social events that included dance-like movements, songs and games. They were exclusive to America, but known to thrive in the frontier and midwestern regions.

It was in these isolated settings where Protestant sects prohibited dancing, yet encouraged play-party activity. 

Play-parties are often compared to nineteenth century singing schools or literary societies because they offered families who lived throughout the countryside a sense of community and entertainment. According to Botkin, play-parties would occur in “the front room or yard of the farm or ranch house, though sometimes the school-house or school-yard was used.”

Participants would play-party as an activity; this phrase describes the act of playing party games (i.e., singing, marching, and dancing games). Those who engaged in the play-party games included the “young people of high school and marriageable age and young married couples,” while older people and young children served as spectators.

Individuals of courting age were particularly interested in the games because they wanted to partake in social activities involving physical and social interactions with the opposite sex.

Like many children’s songs of this era, play-party songs were disseminated through oral tradition. Lyrics of the same song were varied depending on where the lyrics were collected.

[…]

Using Botkin’s terms, play-partiers either based their game songs on older traditional pieces (English and Scottish songs) or newer indigenous pieces (American songs).

Participants often used melodies of the most popular vocal tunes of the era, including blackface minstrel tunes, and change the lyrics to describe the games they were playing.

Botkin theorized that play-party teens specifically chose minstrel songs to create their game songs for three reasons: (1)    most of them were jovial banjo or fiddle tunes, whose airs were used for dancing, (2) their

[page] 4

jesting and clowning had an irresistible appeal for the play-party in its mood of rambling nonsense, with its double taste for silly jingle and burlesque banter, and (3) they had the advantage of wide diffusion by travelling minstrel-troupes [in addition to minstrel song sheet music sales]

Once adapted, minstrel songs survived as fragments of choruses and verses, “or crossed and amalgamated with one another with other songs.”

The most notable minstrel songs that were modified into the American play-party songs were “Old Dan Tucker,” “The Little Brown Jug,” “Shoo Fly, Don’t Bother Me,” “Turkey in the Straw,” “Jump Jim Crow,” and “Jim Along Josey.”

American Blackface Minstrel Songs

American blackface minstrelsy was a form of comedic theatrical performance most recognized today for its use of burnt cork make-up, a type of black body paint that white men and women used on their skin to portray demeaning African American stereotypes.

This stage tradition was first performed in the United States as early as 1822, when British comedian
Charles Mathews created a solo act that parodied his experience in the South by combining skits, stump speeches and black songs.

 By the end of the decade, the American performer Thomas “Daddy” Rice was portraying the character Jim Crow; an uncouth yet happy-go-lucky southern plantation slave. Rice organized the solo act by adding black dialect plantation songs, virtuosic dancing, banjo and fiddle music and crude humor. Another character who appeared on stage during this time an urban freed slave by the name of Zip Coon. The creation of blackface characters such as these, along with Mammy and the picanny, formed pervasive stereotypes often associated with black imagery and behavior.

The classic age of minstrelsy in the United States lasted from the 1840s to the 1870s. The solo act had evolved into duos, trios and eventually quartets that performed during the interludes of theater performances and circus acts. In 1843, The Virginia Minstrels performed the first organized minstrel show and created the standard instrumentation for the quartet ensemble: the fiddle, banjo, bones (castanets constructed from cow bone) and tambourine. Minstrelsy had developed into a full variety show incorporating plantation ballads, instrumental interludes, dance breaks and full chorus numbers.

The music performed on the minstrel stage was catchy to sing, easy to play and fun to dance to. Minstrel songs derived from British dance tunes and resembled songs from the African American tradition. The song form displayed a verse/refrain design where a soloist would sing the verses and a chorus joined in for the refrain. Eventually, the refrain was sung in four party harmony.

The fiddle and banjo eventually became synonymous with the most popular dance crazes of the era; i.e. the Cakewalk, the Walk-Around, the Breakdown, the Buck-And-Wing, the 

[page] 5

Essence Dance, and Jumping Jim Crow.

The irregular rhythms beloved by audiences were created by the animated strumming of the banjo. They enjoyed them so much that minstrel songs often inserted dance breaks at the end of every chorus.

 By the mid-1800s, the minstrel entertainment industry noticed a market for selling the minstrel song through music scores. Instrumental parts written for banjo, fiddle and the piano became accessible to people who wanted to sing and dance to their favorite minstrel tune”

[…]

Case Study

By comparing the original lyrics of  “Jim Along Josey” with the play-party versions, one can begin to understand why the song adaptation had occurred. The song was originally written in 1838 by the minstrel performer Edward Harper, and became a hit as a popular fiddle and dance tune. In his book Scandalize My Name: Black Imagery in American Popular Music, Sam Dennison suggests the first
performance of “Jim Along Josey” was sung by Harper in a blackface drama called The Free Ni--er*
of New York.

The first music score of the song—written for piano—was published in the same year. As shown in Figure 1, the cover reveals that the song was once sung by the “Eminent Professor” John M. Smith, who marketed himself to his audiences as “the celebrated delineator of Etheopean character.”

Blackface minstrelsy was also commonly referred to as Ethiopian (or in this case spelled Etheopean)

[page] 6

minstrelsy throughout the course of the nineteenth century. The sheet music publication distributed the song to a wider audience.

[…]

Oral tradition gave rise to the many interpretations of the lyrics over time.

The original lyrics of “Jim Along Josey” contain racial slurs and allusions that are inappropriate for a child today. These African American stereotypes and themes were commonly applied in minstrel songs and sung in what was perceived as an African American dialect:

I’se from Lucianna as you all know,
Dar where Jim along Josey’s all de go,
Dem ni--ars* all rise when de bell does ring,
And dis is de song da dey do sing.
Hey get along, get along Josey,
Hey get along, get along Jo!

The minstrel character, Jim Along Josey, was always represented as a dandy; a Northern freed slave who pretentiously attempted to dress in the latest aristocratic fashion. Additionally, this caricature often attempted to self-identify as whiter than other black individuals.

The second verse describes this character:

Oh! When I gets dat new coat which I expects to hab soon,
Likewise a new pair tight-kneed trousaloon,
Den I walks up and down Broadway wid my Susanna,
And de white folks will take me to be Santa Anna.
 Hey get along, get along Josey,
 Hey get along, Jim along Joe!

According to Botkin, the chorus is using the American slang phrase hey get along which is an instruction for one to move out of the way. This phrase is also synonymous with the expression to move along.

In addition to the provided dance break at the end of the piece, the chorus lyrics instructs the dancer to move. This dance was a form of breakdown which was associated with the African American folk dances that often occurred on plantations.

[page] 7

Of course, minstrel dances were never to be participated in by the play-party youth because dance was forbidden amongst rural American Protestants.

One former play-partier, Vance Randolph, recalled the church’s condemnation for all dance related activities: 
Less than a dozen years ago the people of my own village refused to allow a children's dancing-class in the town, and I myself heard one of our leading citizens declare that he would rather see his daughter dead than to have her dance, even in her own home. But the play-party, it appears, is a different matter altogether, and even the most fanatical religionists see no particular harm in it. The party-games are really dances, of course, but there is no orchestra; the players furnish their own simple music by singing lustily as they go through the intricate figures.

 Any actions alluding to dance were viewed as sins that created sexual desires. The playpartiers were not ones to overtly participate in these activities because they respected the authorities of the church. However, they were still interested in creating flirtatious physical contact with the opposite sex. Not being allowed to use the minstrel instrumentation associated with the dance music of this time, the teens were subjected to use vocal song to organize their play-party game activities instead. This enabled them to create lyrics that instructed movements, which resembled forbidden dances.

Within the context of the play-party, these movements were not regarded as sin. This is further highlighted by former play-party participant Mrs. L. D. Ames:
These play-parties were really dances. The players did not dance, however, to the music of instruments, but kept time with various steps to their own singing. But they were not called dances: they were called simply parties. The better class of people in the country did not believe in dancing. Regular dances, where the music was furnished by a " fiddler," were held, for the most part, only in the homes of the rough element.

[…]

The preference for vocal accompaniment at play parties arose from the European and North American history or folklore that associated particular instruments with the Devil and evil spirits. Thus, aside dances, instrumentation in play-party contexts also had negative connotations

In his chapter entitled, “The Devil, the Fiddle, and Dancing,” folklorist Herbert Halpert describes this ideology:
The Devil is known for his skill in playing the fiddle, an instrument which some reports say he invented. Sometimes he has contests with human fiddlers. If he teaches people to  

[page] 8

play, they become superlative performers. When he or his pupils are invited to play at dances, their music may be compulsive; people who hear it are forced to dance. Sometimes they cannot stop dancing until they die—unless the spell is broken, frequently by religious mean. Instruments he or his pupils have played may continue to play themselves after the pupil’s death.

[…]

The fear of the fiddle’s evil connotations engendered a creative space, the play-party, where vocal accompaniment could replace the fiddle’s function. On the performance of dance movements, one play-party version of “Jim Along Josey,” found in Iowa, describes physical movement and the embrace of another participant. Also, notice the use of the spelling “Josie” as opposed to “Josey” and the use of the phrase “Get along,” instead of “Jim along.” This illustrates how this song was orally transmitted and therefore required no universal spelling of the song lyrics:

Hey, come a get along,
Get along, Josie.
Hey, come a get along.
 Get along Jo.
If I was single and wanted a beau,
I’d fly to the arms of Jim along Jo.

A very similar version of the song was collected by Botkin in his dissertation. As mentioned before, these lyrics were collected in Oklahoma:

Hey, come a get along,
Get along, Josie.
Hey, come a get along.
Get along Jo.
 All you girls that want a beau,
 Fall in the arms of the calico.

[page] 9

The movements of this next version of “Jim Along Josey ” found in Eastern Illinois, reflect a tag game that results in the male and female hugging as a prize. Also, these lyrics have added reference to animals and nonsense scenarios, which reflect the children’s song aesthetic:

Cat’s in the cream jar,
Run, girls, run!
Fire in the mountains,
 Fun, boys, fun!
 Hey, Jim along, Jim along Josie!
 Hey, Jim along, Jim Along, Jo.

For this version, participants form a circle of couples with the boy standing to the rightside of the girl. Once the singing commenced a girl leaves her spot in the circle to run to the other side. As she attempts to return to her original spot, a boy across the circle tries to catch her. If he accomplishes this, he wins the embrace with the girl. This could also be described as a tag game, so therefore the movements in this song could be applied to other play-party tag game games too.

This next set of lyrics is from Western Nebraska and while the song is not titled “Jim Along Josey” it shares a similar chorus with the previous versions. Instead, this song is called “Hi, Come Along!”:

Hitch my oxen to the cart
And go down the hill to get a load of bark
Hi, come along, Jim along Josie,
Fetch him along, Jim along Jo;
Take him along, Jim along Josie,
Fetch him along, Jim along Jo.

The numerous versions of “Jim Along Josey” were collected at the turn of the twentieth century from different locations across the United States, however, they share similar lyrics.

Whether the lyrics were instructing dance-like movements or expressing nonsense words, the phrase “Jim Along Josey” persisted. Because play-party songs used oral tradition, they served as an effective medium for minstrel songs to survive into the modern day.”…
-snip-
*This word is fully spelled out in this article.

The words in italics were written that way in this article.

****
Thanks for visiting pancocojams.

Visitor comments are welcome.

Wednesday, November 16, 2022

Black Faced Minstrelsy In South Africa's Influence On The Custom Of Isicathamiya Groups Wearing White Gloves And Sometimes Making The "Jazz Hands" Gesture

Edited by Azizi Powell

This pancocojams post presents three videos of South Africa's Isicathamaya groups wearing white gloves or (since at least 2017) wearing gloves of another color.

In at least one of these videos, an Isicathamiya  group makes a form of the "jazz hands" gesture.

The content of this post is presented for historical, cultural, and entertainment purposes.

All copyrights remain with their owners.

Thanks to all those who helped develop the vocal performance styles that are featured in this post. Thanks to all those who are quoted in this post and thanks to all those are featured in this post. Thanks to all those are associated with these showcased videos. 

****
PANCOCOJAMS EDITOR'S NOTE
This pancocojams post is published to spark consideration about these topics which hopefully will results in online and offline information about this subject by those who are far more knowledgeable than I am about the influence of black faced minstrelsy upon certain South African vocal performances. 
  
There's no doubt that the Isicathamiya custom of  wearing white gloves (or lately, wearing other color gloves) has its source in 19th century United States black-faced minstrelsy. This pancocojams posts introduces to some people the historical fact that groups of  United States White minstrel groups and United States Black minstrel groups toured South Africa in the late 19th century and the early 20th century, and thus helped birth the creation of  South African minstrel groups and other vocal group performances such as Isicathamiya. (People in the United States may be familiar with Ladysmith Black Mambazo. That group's singing and performance style is based on Isicathamiya, although that group is much smaller than other Isicathamiya groups and their attire is quite different from Isicathamiya groups.) 

The second part that I posit in this post -that some Isicathamiya groups perform the hand gesture that is known as "jazz hands" or "spirit fingers" and that those Isicathamiya hand gestures have their source in black faced minstrelsy is much more questionable. 

When I refer to South African singers "doing jazz hands" I don't mean that they hold (or held) their arms extended from their waist and wiggle their fingers. Instead, their hands are held near the top of their head and their fingers are wiggled.  

I don't know whether the history of Isicathamiya supports the notion that that gesture was commonly done. I also don't know if that gesture is widely done in the 21st century. 

I also don't know whether that gesture that is performed now by Isicathamiya groups (and probably was performed by Isicathamiya groups in the past) has/had its origin in traditional Zulu or other South African ethnic groups' dances. In other words, was that gesture performed by United States black faced minstrels in the 19th century before they toured South Africa?

Furthermore, I don't know whether the "jazz hand" gesture that Isicathamiya groups do (and presumable did in the past) means the same thing/s as jazz hands mean and meant in the United States.  

****
This pancocojams post pre-supposes that its readers have some knowledge about black faced minstrelsy in the United States and black faced minstrelsy in South Africa. This pancocojams post also pre-supposes that its readers are familiar with the history of and how to make the hand gesture that is now known as "jazz hands" or "spirit fingers".

Here's a quote from the 2018 pancocojams post entitled "Excerpt From A 1997 article About Isicathamiya Music (The Music Style Popularized By Ladysmith Black Mambazo)" http://pancocojams.blogspot.com/2018/01/excerpt-from-1997-article-about.html

[quoting "Songs Of The Night: Isicathamiya Choral Music From KwaZulu Natal" by Angela Impey https://folklife.si.edu/resources/Festival1997/songsof.htm
..."By the 1920s, minstrel shows had gained widespread popularity throughout South Africa, extending deep into remote parts of the countryside, where traditional performance practices remained relatively unaltered. These shows particularly impressed Zulu migrant workers from the KwaZulu Natal regions, who combined stylistic elements of minstrelsy performance with ingoma (dance characterized by forward-stretching hands and high-kicking footwork) and izingoma zomtshado (Zulu wedding songs closely related in structure to ingoma songs) to form the prototype of present-day isicathamiya song and dance.

The vast number of Zulu men who entered the migrant labor system were made to occupy the marginal spaces of the cities: squalid, single-sex hostels, compounds, and impoverished locations. City dwelling demanded creative responses to the dislocation from home and family and to the new experiences of everyday life. With urban development in South Africa, Blacks formed trade unions, sports organizations, and entertainment clubs. Zulu isicathamiya groups developed a complex network of weekly competitions; they were prescribed and stately occasions, organized around set pieces, as had been the convention of school and mission competitions. Choral groups comprised men who shared regional and kinship ties. While isicathamiya competitions may have originated in Durban and KwaZulu Natal, they soon emerged among Zulu migrants in Johannesburg, where performances took on subtle stylistic differences."...

Also, click https://www.dailymaverick.co.za/article/2021-10-05-so-youve-never-heard-of-reuben-t-caluza-that-needs-to-change/ for the Oct. 5, 2021 article by Emma Dollery entitled "So, you’ve never heard of Reuben T. Caluza? That needs to change."

Here's a brief excerpt of that article: 
[Reuben T.] "
Caluza was born near Edendale, KwaZulu-Natal (then called Natal) in 1895, and, according to this short biography, displayed musical talent at a very early age. His talent was further developed in secondary school, when he attended John Dube’s Ohlange High School, the first school founded by a black South African, and one of the first institutions of higher learning for people of colour. Later, he spent time in America, where he studied music at Hampton University and then Columbia University, after which he returned to South Africa to be appointed the head of Adams College School of Music. 

It was in America that Caluza first encountered ragtime, a genre which originated in African American musical communities and is sometimes credited as a precursor to jazz. Miller expands: “This influence of ragtime had a big impact: Caluza was instrumental in developing and revolutionising the ‘concert form’, freeing it up from static missionary choral performance and rather combining movement/dancing with singing performance, relating to the action-songs of isicathamiya, which became a central part of concert entertainment in South African choral music.”...

Also, click https://esat.sun.ac.za/index.php/Minstrels#The_African_Minstrels for information about black faced minstrelsy in 19th/early 20th century South Africa and a list of a black faced minstrel groups who toured that nation or were from that nation.

Here are two brief excerpts from that page:

 “The Virginia Jubilee Singers and Orpheus McAdoo

An influential jubilee and minstrelsy group who visited South Africa in the 1890s under the leadership of impresario Orpheus McAdoo. The group was also known as the Virginia Concert Company, the Virginia Jubilee Concert Company, McAdoo's Vaudeville Company or even simply as The Jubilee Singers. Their visits are believed to have had a substantial influence on the style of the Cape Coon Carnival

See the Virginia Jubilee Singers”
-snip-
This write up doesn’t note that these performers were Black Americans.

**
"
The cultural influence of the minstrelsy movement in South Africa

The impact of the first visit by the original Christy's Minstrels and the various minstrel-style shows subsequently done by the various garrison theatre companies, visiting professionals and a number of amateur companies, in the course of the 19th century has been quite profound.

One of the most noticeable of the longer-term effects of the exposure to the Christy's performances, is to be seen in the way they directly influenced the form, dress and style of what was long known as the Coon Carnival, or Kaapse Klopse, in Cape Town, put on by troupes hailing from various regions of the larger Cape Town area. The annual event, taking place on the 2nd of January (referred to as "Tweede Nuwejaar), is today called the Cape Minstrel Carnival in English, though still referred to as the Kaapse Klopse in Afrikaans.

Besides this key event, a number of other South African minstrel groups - such as the African Darkies, African Own Entertainers, and the Midnight Follies - became popular, and in their turn influenced township performance in various parts of the country, through their use of so-called "coon" songs and skits borrowed from recordings and sheet music from Britain and the USA."...

**
Click https://www.atlasobscura.com/articles/the-fabulous-history-of-jazz-hands "The Fabulous History of JAZZ HANDS!" Here's a brief excerpt from that article:

..."The exact origins of jazz hands are a bit murky, but as with most performative dance, it likely has its roots in African dance traditions. “I see one thread of it coming up through the African-American foundation of jazz dance, and that authentic jazz tradition,” says Rebecca Katz Harwood, Associate Professor of Musical Theater at the University of Minnesota, Duluth. ”In as much as vaudeville grows out of minstrelsy, that’s another step backwards on the family tree of jazz hands.”

It’s likely that the simple act of shaking your hands as part of the performance came into use when vaudeville performers began taking their cues from these traditions. As vaudeville began evolving into film, it brought jazz hands with it. Some people contend that jazz hands can be traced back to Al Jolson’s 1927 film, The Jazz Singer. In the film, Jolson plays a young man who defies his strict Jewish parents, and becomes a singer. The film is mainly remembered both for being the first ever “talkie,” with dialogue synchronized to the action, and also for Jolson’s incredibly offensive blackface minstrelsy. The performance numbers in the film, which were praised upon its release, are still somewhat unforgettable today (if you can get past the blackface).

Some of Jolson’s moves are reminiscent of what we would call jazz hands, with arms outstretched and hands extended pleadingly to the audience, but his moves lack the signature shake. “When I think of Al Jolson, I think of the blackface and the white gloves over his hands. And of course part of what those white gloves do is draw attention to the hands,” says Katz Harwood."...


For an example of "jazz hands", click https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=BatoXPSA3HQ "The Simpsons - Jazz Hands", published by AreaEightyNine, Jul 13, 2017.

****
YOUTUBE VIDEOS OF ISICATHAMIYA GROUPS

These videos are given in no particular order and are numbered for referencing purposes only.

SHOWCASE #1: Zulu Messengers , AmaBhoza KaCothoza Umdlalo ka BGK 1

 

Zulu Messengers, Oct 9, 2017
-snip-
I especially want to direct your attention to the song that starts at 55:57 and the portion of  that song that begins at 1.01:17.  I believe that the  wide eyes, big smile, and wiggling white gloved hands next to their faces definitely resemble black face minstrelsy. 

****
SHOWCASE VIDEO #2: UMDLALO Wase MzimkhuluNMZ



NMZ Multimedia, Aug 16, 2017

-snip-
9:52 in this video shows the group leader holding his hands above his face, wiggling those hands, and grimacing. That grimacing is part of a longer series of mimicking movements, and differs from the "happy/excited" emotions that are conveyed by "jazz hands".    

****
SHOWCASE VIDEO #3: Inkululeko ejajini (Iphimbo Iscathamiya Music Organization)



Inkululeko, Nov. 29, 2021

-snip-
This contemporary Iscathamiya group incorporated Zulu dance movements into their performance. The leader performed a large number of imitative hand gestures. While I didn't see anything that I'd call the "jazz hands" gesture that is performed near the top of the head as I've seen it in the video given as #1 in this pancocojams post, wouldn't have been out of place among these other imitative gestures.  

****
ADDENDUM
I haven't come across any videos of the world famous Isicathamiya and mbube group Ladysmith Black Mambazo wearing Western suits and gloves like the other Isicathamiya groups. It's likely that they wore suits and white gloves when they were competing in isicathamiya competitions. (They won so often that they were asked to stop competing).

If you've come across Ladysmith Black Mambazo or any other Isicathamiya group doing "jazz hands" (other than waving goodbye as at 1:21 in this video https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=Sghfvbd0Nbg , please share that link or links.)

Also, if you have any other information about the imitative movements and hand gestures these groups make, please share that information. Thanks! 
 
****
Thanks for visiting pancocojams.

Visitor comments are welcome.




Saturday, September 24, 2022

What "Hamfatter" & "Ham" Mean As Colloquial References to Actors & Actresses

Edited by Azizi Powell

Latest revision- Jan 9, 2023

This pancocojams post presents online excerpts about the late 19th century/early 20th century colloquial meanings of the word "ham" with a focus on the word "hamfatters" and the song "Ham Fat Man".

The content of this post is presented for linguistic, historical, and cultural purposes.

All copyrights remain with their owners.

Thanks to all those who are quoted in this post.   
-snip-
Portions of this post are included in this pancocojams post: https://pancocojams.blogspot.com/2022/09/the-history-of-hoochie-coochie-dance.html "The History Of The Hoochie Coochie Dance (including information about The Song "Ham Fat Man")"

Click https://pancocojams.blogspot.com/2022/09/what-african-american-vernacular.html for a related pancocojams post entitled "
What The African American Vernacular English Phrase "H.A.M" ("Going Ham") Means"

****
SELECTED ONLINE EXCERPTS
These excerpts are given in no particular order and are numbered for referencing purposes only. 

EXCERPT #1
From https://esnpc.blogspot.com/2016/07/part-ii-history-and-etymology-of.html#:~:text=The%20exotic%2C%20erotic%20form%20of,dance%E2%80%9D%20or%20danse%20du%20ventre The History and Etymology of the "Hoochie-Coochie" Dance, Peter Jensen Brown,  July 8, 2016
"
Part II - the History and Etymology of the "Hoochie-Coochie" Dance

The Ham Fat Man

Both “hoochie-coochie” (derived from “coochie coochie”) and “coochie-coochie” (an altered form of kouta-kouta) may have been derived, at least in part, from a general familiarity with what was then a decades-old song lyric, “hootchy, kootchy, kootchy, I’m the Ham Fat Man.”  “The Ham Fat Man” was a staple of black-face minstrelsy in the 1860s, but is best known today as the inspiration for the word “hamfatter,” later shortened to “ham,” meaning a bad actor.

The earliest reference I could find to the song is in a report of a military construction battalion of free black workers erecting the defenses around Baltimore during the American Civil War:

[...]

At the time, the song was only a few years old.  The earliest indication of the song that I’ve found is an instruction to sing the early Civil War song, “The Union Man” (published in 1861) to the tune of “The Ham Fat Man.”[xiv]

Although Baltimore’s construction battalion is quoted as having sung, “Coochee, Coochee, Coochee,” other published versions of the song, and later reminiscences of the song, generally recite the lyric, “hoochy, koochy, koochy” (or equivalent).[xv]  Alternate versions of the song, however, used “rooksey, cooksey, cooksey[xvi] or “roochy coochy coochy.”[xvii]

The song, or performers who sang the song, seem to have been wildly popular for a time; with several rival performers claiming to be the “original” “Ham Fat Man.”  But by 1865, the song had already overstayed its welcome…

[…]

By 1903, with many of the old-time blackface performers dying away, the song may have reached such a level of obscurity that the origin of the term “hamfatter” (bad actor) was not widely known.  An old-timer explained the origins of the term for a new generation:

Perhaps from the giving away of ham at Pastor’s the impression may prevail that that’s just how the term ‘hamfatter’ for a bad performer originated but this is not so.

The expression is an old minstrel term and came from the refrain of a song and dance which goes something like this: ‘Ham fat, ham fat, smoking in the pan.’  This song became popular, and the performers and later the public caught up the term.  When a minstrel or a variety actor appeared and he was not up to the standard they used to yell at him, ‘Ham fat, ham fat, smoking in the pan.’  And this was abbreviated until poor actors were known as ‘hamfatters.’

The Rock Island Argus (Rock Island, Illinois), June 13, 1902 (reprint from the New York Sun).

Ham Fat Men

The “Ham Fat Man” was more than just a character in a minstrel show; he was based on an actual occupation.  Other occupations were also subject to parody by the minstrels.  One song book of the period[xix], for example, has songs about, “The Soap Fat Man” (another name for the “ham fat man”), “The Stage Driver,” “The Pop-Corn Man,” “The Charcoal Man,” “The Rat-Catcher’s Daughter,” “The Shop Gals,” and “The Candle Maker’s Daughter.”

Not long since a class of traders called “soap fat men” used to go from house to house exchanging soap for the refuse fat accumulated by housewifes.

The Democrat (London), Volume 2, Number 23, December 5, 1885, page 178.

Soap-fat men, or ham-fat men, were at the low end of the food chain.  Ham-fat men went door to door collecting leftover ham and bacon grease for delivery to a soap boiler.  The soap boiler, in turn, made soap and tallow candles to be sold or traded back to the households donating the fat.  A nostalgic piece from 1920 described the business as practiced in one neighborhood in Washington DC:

Who remembers the soap factory on the banks of Rock Creek at the terminus of Twenty-fifth and U streets, where you could take a quart bucket of grease and get a long bar of common soap, good for family washing, household scrubbing, etc?

The Washington Times (Washington DC), May 23, 1920, page 16.

A description of a poor neighborhood in which a quack doctor treated patients at the police station in the early 1800s lumps “soap-fat men” in with a number of other lowly trades:

These, however, were the aristocrats of my practice; the bulk of my patients were soap-fat men, rag-pickers, oystermen, hose-house bummers, and worse, with other and nameless trades, men and women, white, black, or mulatto.

The Century, volume 59, number 15, page 114.

[…]

But the “Ham Fat Man” did have one advantage; he had an opportunity to meet all of the women, cooks and kitchen staff in the neighborhood.  Like the milk man of later generations, the “Ham-Fat Man” of song was a sort of neighborhood lothario; precisely the kind of man who might be the “someone in the kitchen with Dinah,” another staple of minstrel performances.

The Lyrics

The various versions of “The Ham-Fat Man” and “The Soap Fat Man” that I have seen, involve a relationship with someone on his fat-collection route.  In “The Soap Fat Man,” which does not appear to be the same song, although it relates to a similar character, he seduces an “old maid” who is “fifty-six with a face of tan”; takes her to a “lager bier” garden; convinces her lend him $10 to open his own beer garden; and then absconds with the funds; as “he’d a wife and seven children, had the soap fat man.”

Two versions of “The Ham-Fat Man” may also offer a peek into social conditions that led to the development of so-called, “Soul Food;” traditional foods associated with African-American culture in the South.  Although some features of soul food relate back to grains and vegetables brought over from Africa, other elements of soul food reflect the practice of slave “owners” feeding their captive workers as cheaply as possible.  Slaves had to make do with what were considered less desirable “greens,” as well as less desirable cuts of meat.  The “Ham-Fat” Man is satisfied with the fat of the ham; who needs veal, venison, chicken, hare or lamb:

Oh! good-ev'n to you, white folks,
I'm glad to see you all,
I'm right from ole Virginny,
Which some people say will fall;
You may talk about ole massa,
But he am just de man,
To make de n[-words] happy
Wid de ham-fat man.

Chorus.

Ham-fat, ham-fat, zig a zig a zam,
Ham-fat, ham-fat frying in de pan;
Oh! roll into de kitchen fast, boys, as you can,
Oh! rooksey, cooksey, cooksey, I'm de ham-fat man.

Ole missus she's up stair
A-eating bread and honey;
Massa's in de store
A-counting ob his money;
But Susan's in de kitchen
Frying at de ham,
And saving all de gravy
For de ham-fat man.-Chorus.

Some n[-words] likes de mutton,
Puddin', cakes and jam;
Some like veal and venison,
Chicken, hare and lamb.
But of all dese birds and beastesses
Dat plow the raging main,
Dey're not to be compared
To gravy in de pan - Chorus.


In this version, his relationship with Susan seems to be a good one; she saves her “gravy” and “ham fat” just for him, in what may be a mildly naughty sexual suggestion.

In another version, the “Ham Fat Man” is jealous of his rivals; and his “yaller gal’s” loyalty may be suspect:

When wittels am so plenty, oh! I bound to get my fill;
I know a pretty yaller gal, and I lover her to kill,
If any n[-word] fools wid her, I’ll tan him if I can,
A Hoochee, Koochee, Koochee, says the Hamfat man.

A third version of the song involves a more brazen cheater, who leaves town with an Asian man:

White folks attention, and listen to my song
I’ll sing to you a ditty and it won’t detain you long
It’s all about a pretty girl, whose name was Sara Ann
And she fell deep in love with the ham fat man.

Ham fat, soap fat, candle fat or lard,
Ham fat, cat fat, or any other man,
Jump into the kitchen as quick as you can,
With my roochee, coochee, coochee, the ham fat man.

Now the ham fat man, he couldn't stand the press
For every day she wanted to buy a new dress
His money it was gone and the faithless Sara Ann
She hooked it off to Bathurst with a Chinaman

Elements of the second and third versions point to another early influence on the song; a traditional Irish song called, “The Cuckoo’s Nest.”  Both versions are about a woman who is, or may be, unfaithful, and the third version, from Australia, is said to be sung to the tune of “The Cuckoo’s Nest.”"...

****
Excerpt #2
From https://www.quora.com/What-is-the-origin-of-the-term-ham-for-an-over-eager-performer
answer by 
Jonathon Green, 2012
I am a lexicographer and establishing etymologies is a central part of making a dictionary

"Ham is an abbreviation of hamfatter, a second-rate and thus impoverished actor who was forced to rub hamfat over their face, as a base for the powder that was then applied, rather than being able to afford sweeter smelling oils. Although the practise suggests a much earlier use, both terms are so far first recorded in the 1880s. A more recent synonym is scenery-chewer.

The Century Dictionary (1889) suggests an origin in a black song ‘The Ham-Fat Man‘; hamfat was also used by old-time jazzmen to grease the slides of their trombones – thus the 1930s band The Harlem Hamfats; note U. of Missouri use (in 1931) ham, ‘one of unpolished manners’ and Baker et al., College Undergraduate Slang Study (1967–8), ham, ‘a person who always fools around’; note also 1939 reference to a lard actor, ‘an early professional version of “ham actor”,’ in a Federal Writers’ Project essay on Vaudeville, suggesting that lard, rather than ‘hamfat’ was a substitute for cold cream as a basis for make-up.

Although ham is primarily associated with the stage, it can also be used of any species of incompetent, especially one who poses as more expert than their performance – often in sport – shows him to be; an incompetent boxer, a poor fighter".

****
EXCERPT #3
From https://www.worldwidewords.org/articles/ar-ham1.htm  World Wide Words.org- Ham
Copyright © Michael Quinion, 1996–
"A ham or ham actor is one who struts his piece upon the stage to little effect, a fifth-rate artiste of the sort that P G Wodehouse said “couldn’t play the pin in Pinafore”. He may fail because he is an unskilled amateur, though the word is more often applied to a thespian who overacts in a theatrical or ranting way to compensate for his poor grasp of technique or to upstage his fellow actors.

The term is American and dates from the nineteenth century. Where it comes from has been the subject of more inventive etymology than you can shake a stick at. It’s said to be from Hamlet’s advice to the actors (“O, it offends me to the soul to hear a robustious periwig-pated fellow tear a passion to tatters, to very rags, to split the ears of the groundlings”), though why it had to wait 300 years to appear is not explained. A related idea is that the word comes from the title of the play, which is one that amateurs frequently perform badly. Others argue it’s from a Cockney pronunciation of amateur, hamateur, but that would put the origin on the wrong continent.

In the 1860s, ham began to be used in America for somebody who was stupid, clumsy or worthless, especially an untalented prize fighter. This is most likely to have been borrowed from ham-handed or ham-fisted, meaning a person with large hands that fancifully resembled the prepared ham of a pig, hence clumsy.

In a separate development in the 1870s, ham began to be applied to variety performers, who were looked down on by “legitimate” actors. It was also used for incompetents within the profession generally:

Ham — is the most derisive word in the professional vocabulary, and if you wish to lose the friendship of anyone in the business call him a “ham,” and that settles it. A person who can do nothing at all, can not speak his lines properly or is any way bad in his calling, is denominated a “ham”.
Cincinnati Enquirer, 7 Sep. 1879.

In this sense, it’s almost certainly an abbreviation of the slightly older hamfatter:

“When Dellaven proposed this concert business, I told him I was no ham-fatter, and — ” “Ham-fatter?” “Yes. Ham-fatter. That’s the name we give a man in our profession who is a poor performer.”
Nashville Union and American, 6 Nov. 1874.

The consensus is that the source lies with low-paid performers in minstrel troupes, who had to make do with ham fat for cleaning off make-up after a performance rather than a more expensive cream. It seems likely that a mental association grew up with the existing sense of ham for a clumsy or useless person. Another link may have been hambone, slang for a third-rate minstrel performer; this is said — not entirely convincingly — to come from trombonists in such troupes using ham fat to grease the slides of their instruments, slangily known as bones.

Ham later became a term for an amateur radio enthusiast. There has been much controversy about where the term comes from, but it seems certain that it’s connected to ham in the sense of clumsy. With that meaning it was used in the 1890s by US railway telegraphers to describe ill-trained, slow and inaccurate Morse-code operators. It seems to have been adopted early in the next century as an inverted badge of honour by early radio experimenters, who also communicated using Morse code."

****
EXCERPT #4
[Pancocojams Editor's Note: I assigned numbers to the entries that are found below for referencing purposes only. These numbers don't coincide with the order of the entries in that blog post.]

From https://english.stackexchange.com/questions/167630/why-is-an-actor-sometimes-called-ham#:~:text=ham%20actor.&text=The%20word%20Ham%20to%20mean,which%20dates%20from%20about%201863.&text=Interesting. "Why Is An Actor Sometimes Called Ham?"

1. "The word Ham to mean an "overacting inferior performer," apparently dates from about 1882 and orignates from American English. Originally the word was hamfatter, meaning "actor of low grade," and has been linked to an old minstrel show song, "The Ham-fat Man" which dates from about 1863.

Sources: https://www.wordnik.com/words/hamfatter"

answered May 2, 2014 at 11:39
Ilythya

**
2. "Ham means Not a professional or Not a member of a paid profession. An amateur, as in an unpaid radio operator, is also called a Ham. They are not paid for their work, instead they make their own radios from used parts.

Lacking professional skill—as in a poor theatrical performer. In the history of theater, amateur actors used ham or pig fat as a "poor" homemade theatrical makeup, not professionally applied makeup. Hamming became synonymous with poor acting due to the overuse of greasepaint which was made from ham fat."

edited Oct 31, 2014 at 18:33
Mari-Lou A

answered Oct 31, 2014 at 12:00
john crow

**
3. "Following up on the earlier answers by Ilythya and john crow, I did some research into the theories that ham (in the actorly sense) derives from ham fat or from hamfatter (or from both).

Ham fat or ‘The Ham-fat Man’?

 John Ayto, Word Origins, second edition (2005) includes this comment in its entry for ham:
"Ham in the sense 'performer who overacts', first recorded in the late 19th century, apparently comes from an earlier hamfatter 'bad actor', which may have been inspired by the Negro minstrel song 'The Ham-fat Man'."

This bolsters Ilythya’s answer; but john crow’s answer finds support, too, in Martin Harrison, The Language of Theatre (1993):
"The most plausible derivation, with a more detailed and credible etymological story, is that in C19, before the invention of Leichner make-up, powder make-ups were combined with some form of grease or oil before application. Amateurs, or actors on a low income—that is, those who tended to be inferior—were forced to employ cheaper substances (rather than the professionals’ sophisticated oils) to apply their make-up, hence the nicknames ham-bone and ham-fat(ter) from the fact that they used ham-rind and other unpleasant greases as a medium. Ham-fatter may come directly from a negro minstrel song, ‘The Hamfat Man’.

Michael Macrone, Animalogies (1995) brings the “ham grease” and “Hamfat Man” theories together in a somewhat different way from Harrison [combined snippets]:
"The title [“The Hamfat Man”] refers to the minstrels' use of hog grease to clean the black off their faces. It's very likely that the tune inspired the phrase ham actor or ham for short, although such epithets as hamfat man or hamfat actor may predate it. In any case "ham" appeared on its own by 1882, when someone referred to himself, in a letter to in a letter to Illustrated Sports and Drama News, as "no ham, but a classical banjo player."

So one source says that ham fat was used to blend with powder make-up before application, and another that ham fat was used to remove blackface makeup (presumably burnt cork) after application.

Earliest occurrence of ‘Hamfatter’

According to Iris Blake, “Burlesque: Music, Minstrelsy, and Mimetic Resistance” (2013), “The Ham Fat Man” was an 1863 minstrel song show, which also (she says) is the first song to include the words “hootchy cootchy,” albeit in a primitive phonetic spelling. The chorus of the song:

Ham fat, ham fat, zigga zolla zan,
Ham fat, ham fat, Tickle olla tan;
oh! Walk into de kitchen, as fast as you can,
Hoochee Koochee Koochee, says the Hamfat Man


Early notice of the term hamfatter appears in John Farmer, Americanisms Old and New (1889), where the term doesn’t refer to performers of any kind:

HAMFATTER. —A recent name in some quarters of New York, for a second-rate dude or masher, and more especially applied to the habitués of the Rialto in that city.

[Example:] I’ll warrant that these ladies who complain have, if the truth were known, strolled up and down Broadway by the Fifth Avenue Hotel and the Hoffman, and were they so fortunate as to receive an admiring glance from the well-dressed and more prosperous professional brother of the HAMFATTER, they were not offended, forsooth. —New York Herald, July 29, 1888.

Another source indicates that in New York City the term hamfatter was applied colloquially to non-actors by 1879. From George Sala, “All the Fun of the Fair,” (December 3, 1879), in America Revisited, sixth edition (1886):

"Every American who does not wish to be thought “small potatoes” or a “ham-fatter” or a “corner loafer,” is carefully “barbed” and fixed up in a hair-dressing saloon every day."

However, in “Spangles and Sawdust,” in the Nashville [Tennessee] Union and American (November 6, 1879), a “flying trapeze” artist tells the reporter that the term refers to second-rate performers in his profession:

”This is the first [circus] show I ever left in this way. I traveled with Forepaugh’s establishment four seasons, and never had any trouble. I’ve been with this show since the 12th of June last, having joined it at Clinton, Iowa. When DeHaven proposed this concert business, I told him I was no ham-fatter, and—“

“Ham-fatter?”

 “Yes, ham-fatter. That’s the name we give a man in our profession who is a poor performer. I’ve been in the business since I was ten years old, and I’m a little over twenty-five now.”

It’s difficult to think of a form of entertainment where the idea of applying ham fat before a show seems less suitable than in a trapeze act—but that consideration evidently didn’t prevent the minstrelsy term hamfatter from becoming circus slang, too.

The first instance of a performer specifically promoted as a “ham-fatter” appears in an ad for the Vaudeville Theatre in the San Antonio [Texas] Light (April 8, 1884):

"Then comes the noted ham-fatter, CHARLIE FRYE. “If you can guess what he is doing you can have it.”

The same ad mentions that Frye will participate later in the show as a character in “The exceedingly laughable Ethiopian interlude, entitled, Nitro-Glycerine!” which is evidently one of the high points of the evening.

Other uses of ham fat in popular entertainment

From Rosemarie Ostler, Let’s Talk Turkey: The Stories Behind America’ Favorite Expressions (2008):

"According to tradition, ham fat was part of the equipment of old jazz musicians. A 1966 New Yorker piece on Louisiana music alludes to this claim: “Most of the musicians playing in these clubs are old men…. They’re hamfat musicians. In the old days, the rough musicians kept pieces of ham fat in their pockets to grease the slides of their trombones.” By the time [George] Sala used the word in his book [in 1879], it had become synonymous with a third-rate performer or other low-class person."

Conclusions
I was surprised that multiple sources endorsed the theory that ham fat as preparation for makeup (or as a post-performance cleanser of makeup) inspired the minstrelsy song “the Ham Fat Man.” An alternative theory might be that “Ham Fat Man” was simply a stock minstrelsy name—like Tambo, Jim Crow, and Mr. Bones—that had no reference to practical uses of ham fat on the stage.

In any event, the argument that “ham actor” is derived from hamfatter seems quite strong, even though the term hamfatter was also used in connection with forms of entertainment besides stage acting, and indeed was sometimes applied to people who were not entertainers at all.

UPDATE (3/24/2016): I consulted a new (to me) glossary of theater terms to see what it might add to the discussion. Here is the entry for ham in Don Wilmeth, The Language of American Popular Entertainment: A Glossary of Argot, Slang, and Terminology (1981) [combined snippets]:

"Ham or ham actor. An amateur or professional actor who is affected, self-indulgent, or conceited, and who tends to strive for attention over the other actors on the stage by overplaying. A number of theories to the origin of this unflattering epithet have been posed. Two possibilities involve the operation of Tony Pastor, the early vaudeville manager. He had an act in his downtown establishment called "The Hamtown Students," a black-face quartet known for their exaggerated movements and the overblown nature of their act. Supposedly, whenever Pastor saw an actor who was overplaying he described him as a "ham." Others apparently used the full name, "Hamtown student." Another theory is that a poster at Pastor's Opera House in New York announced "sixty hams distributed on Monday evening." This offering of free hams, according to the theory, began to reflect poorly on the actors until they were known as "ham actors." H.L. Mencken suggested that it came from Hamlet, since all actors either claimed to have played Hamlet to great applause—or wished to play Hamlet. He further pointed out that an old name for an amateur was hambone. It has been said that the term actually came from a name associated with Hamish McCullough (1835–1885), who toured the "pig-sticking" towns of Illinois with a fit-up or portable company. His nickname was Ham and his troupe was called Ham's actors. The most sensible origin is that the word is short for hamfatter, the emollient or lard derived from pork and ham used by old-time actor and minstrel men to remove their makeup. It was common before the advent of cold cream and later, when col cream was available, was just as effective and cheaper."

edited Jun 15, 2020 at 7:40
CommunityBot

answered Nov 1, 2014 at 7:22
Sven Yargs

****
Thanks for visiting pancocojams.

Visitor comments are welcome.