Three Jolly Fishermen
Wee Sing - Topic, Jun 7, 2018
This pancocojams post showcases a YouTube song file of the English language children's "naughty" song "There Were Three Jolly Fishermen".
The content of this post is presented for folkloric, socio-cultural, and entertainment purposes.
All copyrights remain with their owners.
Thanks to the unknown composers of this song. Thanks to the collectors of this song and the creator/s of the sound file that is embedded in this video. Thanks also to all those who are who are quoted in this post.
-snip-
****
DISCLAIMER
The mission of this pancocojams blog is to showcase the cultures of Black people in the United States and elsewhere in the world. As such, most of the songs that are showcased in this blog were composed by Black people.
However, while the song "There Were Three Jolly Fisherman" has certainly been sung by Black people (including me), this post doesn't mean to imply that it was originally created by Black people. The original composers of Three Jolly Fishermen" are unknown, but early examples of this song are from locations in England where there weren't any Black people.
[Read Source #1 comments in this post.]
****
LYRICS - THREE JOLLY FISHERMEN
There were three jolly fishermen,
There were three jolly fishermen,
Fisher, fisher, men, men, men,
Fisher, fisher, men, men, men,
There were three jolly fishermen.
The first one's name was Abraham,
The first one's name was Abraham,
Abra, Abra, ham, ham, ham,
Abra, Abra, ham, ham, ham,
The first one's name was Abraham.
The second one's name was I-I-saac,
The second one's name was I-I-saac,
I-I, I-I, saac, saac, saac,
I-I, I-I, saac, saac, saac,
The second one's name was I-I-saac.
The third one's name was Ja-a-cob,
The third one's name was Ja-a-cob,
Ja-a, Ja-a, cub, cub, cub,
Ja-a, Ja-a, cub, cub, cub,
The third one's name was Ja-a-cob.
They all went up to Jericho,
They all went up to Jericho,
Jer-i, Jer-i, cho, cho, cho,
Jer-i, Jer-i, cho, cho, cho,
They all went up to Jericho.
They should have gone to Amsterdam,
They should have gone to Amsterdam,
Amster, amster, shh, shh, shh,
Amster, amster, shh, shh, shh,
They should have gone to Amsterdam."
-https://www.scoutsongs.com/lyrics/threejollyfishermen.html
-snip-
The "shh" letters approximates the sound that is made when people vocalize the "be quiet" command with one finger in front of their mouth.
These are standard lyrics for this children's song. Other versions of this song are included in this pancocojams post.
****
INFORMATION AND COMMENTS ABOUT THERE WERE THREE JOLLY FISHERMEN"
From https://mudcat.org/thread.cfm?threadid=30614
Subject: RE: Lyr Add: Three Jolly Fishermen
1. Michael in Swansea, 09 Feb 01 - 07:41 AM
THREE JOLLY FISHERMEN
We are three jolly fishermen
We are three jolly fishermen
We are three jolly fishermen
While the merry merry bells do ring
Chorus: Make haste make haste
You'll be too late
One fish my dear
I cannot wait
For me fine fry of herring
Me bonnie silver herring
Mind how you sell them
While the merry merry bells do ring
We cast our nets into the sea (deep) x3
While the merry ..... etc
We've fine and speckled bellied un's x3
While the merry ..... etc
We sell them three four fourpence x3
While the merry ..... etc
..."Song originating from Whitby in Yorkshire"...
** 3. Michael in Swansea, Date: 10 Feb 01 - 05:01 AM
"Didn't know that, thanks Dave.
Lovely place Whitby, go there every October for the shanty festival." ** 4. mandomad, 10 Feb 01 - 07:22 AM
"Hi Mike, Yes, we see you on the Sunday night when you turn up in the Tap & Spile for a after Festival sing/sup. We know the second verse as...We'll cast our nets unto the rocks(3).
"The merry,merry bells do ring," are ,of course the Bells of St Mary's church up on the cliff top. Do drop into the Tap again this year,and give us a song (with as many of your shanty lads as can manage. We might just persuade Derek Elliott to give his well known rendition of the above song Cheers.
Tony(Mandomad)
The noisy one in the corner."
** 5. Malcolm Douglas Date: 12 Feb 02- 10:03 AM "Roy Palmer prints a slightly different set in The Oxford Book of Sea Songs (1986), now revised and reprinted as Boxing the compass. He comments:"Steve Gardham recorded this from Thomas Calvert of Runswick Bay, North Yorkshire, in 1971. The song, which seems to have been a particular favourite in the Whitby area (though Cecil Sharp had a version from Middlesex, attached to a dance), was issued on a broadside printed in 1837-8 by W. and T. Fordyce, Newcastle, under the title of Caller Herring. This in turn loosely derives from a song of the same name by Lady Carolina Nairne (1766-1845), published in 1824 to a tune by Nathaniel Gow (1777-1831), based on 'the original Cry of the Newhaven fish wives, Selling their fresh herrings in the streets of Edinburgh'. Gow's tune was issued as a shilling music sheet for piano in c.1802."
**
6. Dave Bryant, Date: 12 Feb 02 - 12:50 PM
"Alan, You were around at Stony on Saturday night when Linda and I sang it - although we sing it as "Two" rather than "Three" fo obvious reasons. There is another verse after "We cast our nets into the sea"
We bring them fresh to market.
I first heard it sung many years ago by Derek & Dorothy Elliot, and we basically use their arrangement of Linda (& chorus ladies) singing the "Make Haste, Make Haste" and "One fish my dear" lines, and me (and chorus men) singing "You'll be too late" and "I cannot wait" lines.
I had heard that it referred to Staithes, further up the coast from Whitby, where the fisherfolk were very religious (Plymouth Brethren?). When the boats landed with the catch, fish were only on sale for a short time before the fisherfolk would have to attend prayers to give thanks. It's an interesting story anyway. I can remember women from Staithes selling fish at Stockton market when I was up in the NE during the 60s. They used to wear long black skirts and bonnets rather like the Sally Army ones."
-snip-
This comment is the first one that I've come across that connects the sea song "There Were Three Jolly Fishermen" with the contemporary song of the same title that is considered a Christian children's song.
"The Sally Army" referred to in the quoted comment was a colloquial referent for the Salvation Army
****
SOURCE #2
From https://www.fresnostate.edu/folklore/ballads/FSWB240A.html Once There Were Three Fishermen (The Three Jews)
"DESCRIPTION: "Once there were three fishermen (x2),
Fisher fisher men men men (x3) Once there were three fishermen." The three fishermen are named, and their voyages described.
AUTHOR: unknown
EARLIEST DATE: 1927 (Harbin-Parodology)
FOUND IN: US(MW,Ro) Canada(Mar,Newf)
[...]
Roud #3708 and 12776
NOTES : This is rather confusing, because the change of one word significantly changes the song. In several texts (Gardner and Chickering, Greenleaf and Mansfield), the three heroes are Jews. But in Pankake, as well as the version printed by Silber, they are fishermen. The
latter version is very much a children's song, I've only encountered two versions of this, and they differ in most particulars: In the Silber version, the sailors are Abraham, Isaac, and Jacob, and they sail for Amsterdam (with resulting comments about naughty words); Ed McCurdy sings a version with different sailors, in which Halifax is the destination. It appears Averill-Camp Songs Folk Songs also had the Amsterdam version.
The fact that the three sailors are "Abraham, Isaac, and Jacob" in one of the "Fishermen" versions implies to me that the "Three Jews" version is older; Abraham, Isaac, and Jacob are, of course, the three patriarchs of the Jews, so if they show up in a "Fishermen" version, it's because the names were derived from a "Three Jews" version.
In this case, Roud splits the two versions. But the verse form, as well as the names of the characters, says they are the same."
****
SOURCE #3
From https://mudcat.org/thread.cfm?threadid=107415 Subject: RE: Lyr Add: Three Jolly Fishermen
[Pancocojams Editor's Note: This is a reprint of a very small Mudcat discussion thread. All of the post [comments] are reprinted here except for a comment that I wrote encouraging the first commenter to add his comment to the Biblical Place Name discussion thread that I had started.]
Date: 01 Jan 08 - 06:52 PM
"Astounded that this one is not in the DT or a Mudcat Thread.
Azizi's posting regarding Biblical Places prompted the memory.
Three Jolly Fishermen
There were three jolly fishermen,
There were three jolly fishermen,
Fisher, fisher, MEN, MEN, MEN.
Fisher, fisher, MEN, MEN, MEN.
There weere three jolly fishermen.
The first one's name was Abraham,
The first one's name was Abraham,
Abra, Abra; ham ham, ham,
Abra, Abra; ham ham, ham,
The first one's name was Abraham,
The second one's name was I-I-saac,
The second one's name was I-I-saac,
I-I, I-I- zik, zik, zik, etc.
The third one's name was Ja-a-cob,
The third one's name was Ja-a-cob,
Ja-a, Ja-a; cub, cub, cub, etc.
They all went down to Jericho,
They all went down to Jericho,
Jer-i, Jer-i; cho, cho, cho, etc.
They should have gone to Amsterdam,
They should have gone to Amsterdam,
Amster, Amster, Shh! Shh! Shh!,
Amster, Amster, Shh! Shh! Shh!
You shouldn't say that naughty word!
CAN BE SUNG AS A ROUND
Sincerely,
Gargoyle"
**
2.
Date: 01 Jan 08 - 07:36 PM
Well, I'm glad to know that that the Biblical Place Name Thread inspired this thread.
As to the song Three Jolly Fisherman, the version that I learned along the way {which means I don't remember when I learned it but it probably wasn't when I was a young child} is somewhat different than the version that you posted, Gargoyle. Here's that version:
Three Jolly Fishermen
There were three jolly fishermen, fishermen.
There were three jolly fishermen, fishermen
Fisher, fisher, men, men, men
Fisher, fisher, men, men, men.
There were three jolly fishermen.
The first one's name was Abraham, Abraham
The first one's name was Abraham, Abraham
Abra, Abra, ham, ham, ham.
Abra, Abra, ham, ham, ham.
The first one's name was Abraham.
The second one's name was I-I-saac, Isaac.
The second one's name was I-I-saac, Isaac.
I-I, I-I- zik, zik, zik,
I-I, I-I- zik, zik, zik,
The second one's name was I-I-saac.
The third one's name was Ja-a-cob, Jacob.
The third one's name was Ja-a-cob, Jacob.
Jay-a, Jay-a; cub, cub, cub.
Jay-a, Jay-a; cub, cub, cub.
The third one's name was Ja-a-cob.
They all went down to Amster-shh! Amerster-shh!
They all went down to Amerster-shh!
Amster, Amster, Shh! Shh! Shh!
Amster, Amster, Shh! Shh! Shh!
They all went down to Amster-shh!
You must not say that naughty word! Naughty word.
You shouldn't say that naughty word! Naughty word.
Naughty naughty, word word word.
Naughty naughty, word word word.
You must not say that naughty word!
I'm gonna say it any how, any how.
I'm gonna say it any how, any how.
Any any how how how.
Any any how how how.
I'm gonna say it any how.
They all went down to AmsterDAM. AmsterDAM.
They all went down to AmersterDAM. AmsterDAM.
Amster, Amster, DAM! DAM! DAM!
Amster, Amster, DAM! DAM! DAM!
They all went down to AmsterDAM!
**
Actually, I don't recall singing the last two* verses. However, that's the way it was sung in the summer camp that my children attended in the mid 1990s."
-snip-
Oct. 27, 2022 - Correction- I don’t recall singing the last four verses [ i.e. I believe that the way I remember singing that song is that it ended with the Jacob verse. Also, notice that my version (probably in the late 1950s when I was around age 10 years old and my children's version from the 1990s didn't include the "Jericho" verse.]
3.
Date: 01 Jan 08 - 07:48 PM
**
4. From: Joe_F
Date: 01 Jan 08 - 08:27 PM
5.
Date: 01 Jan 08 - 09:16 PM
****
SOURCE #4
From https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=srb0fdH7yEE [This is the link to the first YouTube sound file that is given in this pancocojams post.]
Here are some comments from this sound file's discussion thread. Numbers have been assigned for referencing purposes only.
"I recall ending the song with 'and now we're going to finish it. And now we're going to finish it. Finney Finney, ** ** **, Finney Finney ** ** **!!' shouting the last words at the top of our lungs in the back of the bus. So naughty. ;)"
**
Reply
2. Zippity Zoop, 2016
"We used say they all went down to Amsterdam: Amster, Amster, dam dam dam!"
**
3. E. Collins, 2018
"In the version from my childhood, after the Amsterdam verse, there was "I must not say that naughty word, etc." Then, "I'm gonna say it anyway, etc." And finally (!), "They all went down to Amster DAM!, etc."...
**
Reply
4. lyncap99, 2021
"Yeah this is the version I remember they all went down to amster-shhh... Must not say that naughty word... Think I'll say it anyway... All went down to amster dam"
**
5. TheHoffy59, 2019
"You should have seen that old peacock. Pea Pea..............."
****
SOURCE #5
https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=0u3ebCWmrRI
4799. Once There Were Three Fishermen (Traditional American)
raymondcrooke, Jan 3, 2025
-snip-
This is a video of Raymond Crooke singing this song while he plays a guitar.
Here are some comments from that video (with numbers added for referencing purposes only.)
1. @JBurdoo, 2025
"I learned this in childhood from Ed McCurdy. It may have
been a Canadian version, as they all went up to Halifax instead. I have fond
memories of it."
Reply
2.
"I have it on his LP, "The Best of Ed McCurdy".
Coincidentally, I met a visitor from Nova Scotia a few days ago who actually
used to perform with Ed McCurdy.
Also known as "Three Jolly Fishermen", this
children’s song is based on the biblical story of three fishermen, Isaac, Jacob
and Abraham. It has been widely recorded and was popular as a scout song."
**
3. @sarawoods1450,2025
"Still remember this from my grade school singing class in
Canada. I don’t think folk songs are taught anymore sadly."
**
Reply
4. @raymondcrooke, 2025
"I hope they are. A pity if they don't keep up the
traditional music."
**
5. @muzvid,2026
"Glad you included the "naughty" bits! That's what
I remember best (of course!), but they've been left out in most other sources
I've found."
****
REPRINT OF THE COMMENTS FROM THE NOW DELETED 2022 PANCOCOJAMS POST ON THIS SONG
AnonymousMarch 19, 2023 at 6:35 PM
****
Thanks for visiting pancocojams.
Visitor comments are welcome

"Three Wandering Jews" or songs with similar titles have lyrics that are very similar to "Three Jolly Fishermen". The tune for "Three Wandering Jews" is the same as the tune for "Three Jolly Fishermen".
ReplyDeleteI don't recommend singing this song because it lends itself to the possibility of people thinking that it makes fun of Jewish people.