Translate

Friday, November 20, 2026

The Possible (Or Probable) Southern Black American Dance Song Sources For The 19th Century Minstrel Song "Jim Along Josie"

Edited by Azizi Powell

This pancocojams post reprints an AI Overview write-up that I received as a result of my question about the possible (or probable) Southern Black American sources for the 19th century minstrel song "Jim Along Josie".

The Addendum to this post presents information about and partial lyrics for Southern Black American dance songs that have been cited as being similar to "Jim Along Josie".

The content of this post is presented for historical and folkloric purposes.

All copyrights remain with their owners.

Thanks to AI Overview for its summary of this information and thanks to all others who are quoted in this post.
-snip-
Click __ for a hyperlinked list of all of the posts about "Jim Along Josie" and "Jump Josie" that have been publish on this pancocojams blog.  If additional posts about these songs are published on this blog, I'll add their links to that post.

****
AI OVERVIEW RESULTS TO MY QUERY ABOUT " JIM ALONG JOSEY"
Query made on November 20, 2026 -Do some folklorist believe that the lyrics for the minstrel song "Jim Along Josie" was adapted or partly or wholly lifted from enslaved African American culture?

"AI Overview

Yes—some scholars, music historians, and folklorists view "Jim Along Josie" (originally "Jim Along Josey") as drawing on or intertwining with African American cultural elements, though its documented authorship begins in blackface minstrelsy around 1838.

• Minstrel authorship vs. adaptation: Most musicological and historical records attribute the song to blackface performer Edward Harper around 1838 (with early sheet music appearing around 1840). Because blackface minstrels routinely drew from, caricatured, and appropriated African American music, dance, and vernacular, scholars debate whether Harper composed the piece largely from scratch or adapted existing African American song fragments and rhythms. 

• Jim Along Josey" and African American dance and folk traditions. Terms like "Josey" have been linked to African American dance steps or slang, and motifs such as a bullfrog or bird with "whooping cough" appear across wider Southern and African American folk song families (such as Limber Jim and Jaybird Died).

• Two-way oral exchange: Rather than a simple one-way theft, folklorists generally emphasize ongoing exchange and "floating" folk lyrics. Once published, the song entered oral tradition among both Black and white communities—appearing in play-party games, fiddle tunes, and later folk collections—where verses were swapped, improvised, and altered over time.”
-snip-
“Jaybird Died” = refers to the folk song “Jaybird Died With A Whooping Cough”.
-snip-
The websites that were cited as sources for this AI overview are Bluegrass Messengers*, Decolonizing the music-Jim Along Josie, and Dulcimer Downloads-Jim Along Josie.

The first two websites that are listed have been given as the sources for other AI Overview results that I have received on the song "Jim Along Josie" and the singing game "Jump Josie".  

*When I attempted to visit the Bluegrass Messenger website, I received a message that it doesn't have a secure connection. As a result of that warning message, I haven't visited that website.   

****
ADDENDUM #1- INFORMATION ABOUT THE SONG "LIMBER JIM"

"AI Overview

"Limber Jim" is an American traditional folk and riverfront song closely tied to the later folk standard "Buckeye Jim" and "Shiloh". 

Historical Roots & Documentation

• Cincinnati Riverfront (1874–1877): Writer Lafcadio Hearn documented "Limber Jim" (also called "Shiloh") among riverfront laborers ("roustabouts") in Cincinnati newspapers.

• Length & Performance: Hearn noted the song could stretch to around 20 minutes with shifting verses, a fast, lively melody, a chanted "Shiloh" chorus, and rhythmic thigh- and hip-slapping known as "patting Juba".

• Field Recordings: Folklorist Fletcher Collins recorded a closely related version ("Buckeye Jim") from Mrs. Patty Newman in Elon College, North Carolina, in 1939. 

Evolution & Related Songs

• Song Family: Scholars and folk musicians group "Limber Jim" with "Buckeye Jim," "Shiloh," and related fiddle/dance tunes such as "Jim Along Josie" and "Goodbye Liza Jane"."...

****

ADDENDUM #1- INFORMATION ABOUT THE SONG "JAYBIRD DIED OF A WHOOPING COUGH"
From https://tunearch.org/wiki/Annotation:Jaybird_Died_of_the_Whooping_Cough
" "Jay Bird Died Of/With The Whooping Cough". Also see "Here Comes Jack With A Fiddle On His Back".  Old-Time, Breakdown. USA; Tennesse, Virginia. G Major. Standard tuning (fiddle). AABB. Charles Wolfe (1991) states that printed versions of this song/tune have been found as far back as 1846, and that it has been fairly widely collected from both black and white sources.

Jaybird Died of the Whooping Cough,
Squirrel died of the colic;
'Long come a red bird sittin' on a fence,
Call all the young girls to frolic.

Put that mule back under o' the shed,
Yonder comes the owner;
Stole his horse and bought me a mule,
And I ain't gonna pay no more.

African-American collector Thomas Talley, in his [1922] book Negro Folk Rhymes (reprinted in 1991, edited by Charles Wolfe), gives the following verses, the last two of which are relatively rare, according to Wolfe:

De Jaybird died wid de Whoopin' Cough,
De Sparrer died wid de colic;
'Long come de Red-bird, skippin' 'round,
Sayin': "Boys, git ready fer de Frolic!"

De Jaybird died wid de Whoopin' Cough,
De Bluebird died wid de Measles;
'Long come a Ni&&er wid a fiddle on his back,
'Vitin' Crows fer to dance wid de Weasels.

Dat Mockin'-bird , he romp an' sing,
Dat ole Gray Goose come prancin',
Dat Thrasher stuff his mouf wid plums,
Den he caper on down to de dancin'.

Dey hopped it low, an' dey hopped it high,
Dey hopped it to, an' dey hopped it by,
Dey hopped it fer, an' dey hopped it nigh,
Dat fiddle an' bow jes make 'em fly.

Wolfe states older printed sources include White (243), Brown (3:201), Browne (447), and an early Tennessee variant appears in the Tennessee Folklore Society Bulletin 2, p. 30. See also the Kentucky variant entitled "Here Comes Jack With A Fiddle On His Back"."
-snip-
*This word is fully spelled out in these lyrics. 
**
Click https://mudcat.org/thread.cfm?threadid=37475 Lyr/Chords Req: JAYBIRD DIED OF THE WHOOPING

Here are two comment from that folk music forum discussion thread (with the second comment referring to a comment that I made on that discussion thread that quoted the Thomas W. Talley lyrics for that song:

1. 
From: Cranky Yankee
Date: 
 06 Aug 01 - 11:25 PM

"I know that line from a song entitled, "Buckeye Jim". It's a REALLY OLD American Hillbilly song. The verse with the "whooping cough" in it goes like this......

A say out yonder in a wooden trough
A jaybird died of the whoopin' cough
Buckeye Jim, you can't go
Go weave and spin, you can't go
Buckeye Jim"

**
2. 

Subject: RE: Lyr/Chords Req: JAYBIRD DIED OF THE WHOOPING

From: Q (Frank Staplin)

Date: 14 Apr 08 - 04:48 PM

 

Thomas Talley provided the music in his "Negro Folk Rhymes," No. 50 p. 32, Revised Ed., pub. 1949, Univ. Tennessee Press. The lyrics are the same as posted by Azizi.

 

Newman I. White, American Negro Folk Songs, reports it from the minstrel song, Jim Along Josie, c. 1846, that date also mentioned by Talley.

 

40A

Over de hills an a great way off

De jaybird died with the hookin' cough,

An a way down in a big muddy pon'

Oh dis jaybird died wid his breeches on.

Reported in C. B. Crow MS, as heard in "Levee Camp on Mississippi River in Louisiana." 1915-1916.

 

"In the "New Jim Along Josey," in "Negro Singers' Own Book," c. 1846, it is the bullfrog who dies of the whooping cough; and in "Go away, go away, Don't Come Nigh," (Ibid.) it is the bulltoad."

 

In the same song book:

 

De toads dey jumped an' de tadpoles danced,

De hogs dey squealed an' de possum pranced.

 

Away down yonder in the forks of de branch,

The jaybird whistled and de buzzard danced- collected in LA 1915-1916.

'Way down yonder in de fork ob de branch

De jaybird say he ain't got much chance. - Heard in ALabama, 1915, sung by grandfather. ((White).

 

Similar verse from ALabama, Blake MS-

Way up yonder on the ole green lake

The bullfrog died with the belly ache,

Just cause he had nothin' else to do,

Just cause he had nothin' else to do.

 

Some verses also reported in Perrow."
-snip-
Notice that the verse from Alabama and Black Mississippi is very similar to the lyrics for "MAY IRWIN'S FROG SONG" (first verse)

Charles E. Trevathan, 1896

"Away down a-yonder in Yankety Yank,
A bullfrog jumped from bank to bank
'Cause there wasn't nothin' else to do.
He stubbed his toe an' in he fell,
An' de neighbors all say dat he went to well,
'Cause he hadn't nothin' else to do."...
-snip-
This song is one of the precursors to "Down By The Banks Of The Hanky Panky" children's hand clap rhyme and children's hand slap singing game . Click 
https://pancocojams.blogspot.com/2023/11/how-certain-song-sources-other-real.html for the 2023 pancocojams post "The Origin Of "Down By The Banks Of The Hanky Panky" (Various Song Sources, Real Life Events, & More)".

****
Thanks for visiting pancocojams.

Visitor comments are welcome.

No comments:

Post a Comment